Clarifying the gray water dumping issue
"Buy a dump cap and fittings that will enable you to connect a common garden hose so that you can drain your gray water off into a hole or onto a thirsty bush, preventing your gray tank from filling up and forcing you to drive off to dump." That statement in my recent Winter desert snowbird tips post revived the questions regarding the legality of dumping gray water on BLM land while bondocking.
So, on September 19th I sent the following email to the BLM:
“I write blogs and magazine articles and teach classes to users of recreation vehicles (RV) on camping in the desert without hookups (boondocking or dry/camping) that have raised questions, for some of which I cannot find a definitive answer. I have always advised that if an RVer cleaned food particles from dishes and utensils before washing, and used biodegradable soaps, the resultant “gray” water could be safely dumped on plants or into a freshly dug hole. Could you please clear up the following questions about camping on BLM land so that I may post to my readers:
Thank you. Bob”
On the 21st I received the following reply:
“Dear Mr. Difley, we have received your request and in order to properly answer your questions are consulting with our field offices to determine if there are any areas that have special restrictions/conditions in place. We will respond to your request once we can compile the responses. Thank you for your interest in BLM public lands.
Carrie Templin
Public Affairs Specialist
Bureau of Land Management”
On Monday, October 4th, I received the following reply. I have hightlighted certain sections that I thought interesting or pertinent in bold type.
"Dear Mr. Difley,
Thank you for your recent questions regarding recreational vehicles (RV) and dispersed camping on BLM lands in Arizona. The answers to your questions are more complicated than originally thought. Although the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) found at 8365.1-1 (3) generally
excludes "wash water" from BLM's prohibition against draining or dumping, it can be specifically prohibited by Supplemental Rules issued for a specific area. This applies equally to RVers and tent campers.
TITLE 43--PUBLIC LANDS: INTERIOR
CHAPTER II--BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, DEPARTMENT OF THE
INTERIOR
PART 8360_VISITOR SERVICES
Subpart 8365_Rules of Conduct
Sec. 8365.1-1 Sanitation.
(3) Drain sewage or petroleum products or dump refuse or waste other than wash water from any trailer or other vehicle except in places or receptacles provided for that purpose;
There are two locations in Arizona where draining wash water is specifically prohibited by Supplemental Rules that have been established and were published in the Federal Register. They are the Long Term Visitor Areas outside of Yuma, Arizona, and Hot Well Dunes Recreation
Area east of Safford, Arizona.
A note of caution to your audience: Under State laws and regulations in Arizona, "wash water" or "gray water" from a kitchen sink or dishwasher is classified as sewage. If discharging it onto the ground from a RV or camper might cause it to enter an aquifer, the visitor could be subject to violation of State of Arizona regulations unrelated to BLM regulations. Even if the gray water is from a clotheswasher, bathroom sink, shower, or bathtub, it can only be discharged if done so according the "General Permit" practices that would apply. The practices are explained at the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.
In addition, if the gray water creates a hazard or a nuisance a Law Enforcement Officer can cite (or in extreme circumstances arrest) an individual. This would go
beyond simple gray water dumping, and the citation would likely be for some other offense related to degradation of resources or public health and safety issues. Law Enforcement Officers in the field have discretion in applying the laws and regulations as necessary and appropriate to protect the natural resources on the ground.
Thank you for your patience, while BLM researched the issue in order to provide accurate answers for your audience,
Carrie Templin
Public Affairs Specialist
Bureau of Land Management
Arizona State Office
(602) 417-9448
The link above to the ADEQ deals mostly with home use of gray water recycling, and offers the following definition: "Gray water is defined as wastewater, collected separately from sewage, that originates from a clothes washer, bathtub, shower or sink, but not from a kitchen sink, dishwasher or toilet. Gray water is distinguished from 'black water,' which is wastewater from toilets, kitchen sinks and dishwashers."
So, on September 19th I sent the following email to the BLM:
“I write blogs and magazine articles and teach classes to users of recreation vehicles (RV) on camping in the desert without hookups (boondocking or dry/camping) that have raised questions, for some of which I cannot find a definitive answer. I have always advised that if an RVer cleaned food particles from dishes and utensils before washing, and used biodegradable soaps, the resultant “gray” water could be safely dumped on plants or into a freshly dug hole. Could you please clear up the following questions about camping on BLM land so that I may post to my readers:
- Are RVers permitted to dump their gray water tanks into a hole dug in the ground or on a plant or bush?
- Are tenters or other non-RV campers permitted to do the same?
- Are RVers permitted to run a garden hose drain from their gray tank to a hole or plant?
- Can RVers throw dishwater from a dish pan onto plants or in a hole?
- If none of the above are permitted, would you please cite the pertinent rule text and location.
- If illegal, what is the fine?
Thank you. Bob”
On the 21st I received the following reply:
“Dear Mr. Difley, we have received your request and in order to properly answer your questions are consulting with our field offices to determine if there are any areas that have special restrictions/conditions in place. We will respond to your request once we can compile the responses. Thank you for your interest in BLM public lands.
Carrie Templin
Public Affairs Specialist
Bureau of Land Management”
On Monday, October 4th, I received the following reply. I have hightlighted certain sections that I thought interesting or pertinent in bold type.
"Dear Mr. Difley,
Thank you for your recent questions regarding recreational vehicles (RV) and dispersed camping on BLM lands in Arizona. The answers to your questions are more complicated than originally thought. Although the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) found at 8365.1-1 (3) generally
excludes "wash water" from BLM's prohibition against draining or dumping, it can be specifically prohibited by Supplemental Rules issued for a specific area. This applies equally to RVers and tent campers.
TITLE 43--PUBLIC LANDS: INTERIOR
CHAPTER II--BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, DEPARTMENT OF THE
INTERIOR
PART 8360_VISITOR SERVICES
Subpart 8365_Rules of Conduct
Sec. 8365.1-1 Sanitation.
(3) Drain sewage or petroleum products or dump refuse or waste other than wash water from any trailer or other vehicle except in places or receptacles provided for that purpose;
There are two locations in Arizona where draining wash water is specifically prohibited by Supplemental Rules that have been established and were published in the Federal Register. They are the Long Term Visitor Areas outside of Yuma, Arizona, and Hot Well Dunes Recreation
Area east of Safford, Arizona.
A note of caution to your audience: Under State laws and regulations in Arizona, "wash water" or "gray water" from a kitchen sink or dishwasher is classified as sewage. If discharging it onto the ground from a RV or camper might cause it to enter an aquifer, the visitor could be subject to violation of State of Arizona regulations unrelated to BLM regulations. Even if the gray water is from a clotheswasher, bathroom sink, shower, or bathtub, it can only be discharged if done so according the "General Permit" practices that would apply. The practices are explained at the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.
In addition, if the gray water creates a hazard or a nuisance a Law Enforcement Officer can cite (or in extreme circumstances arrest) an individual. This would go
beyond simple gray water dumping, and the citation would likely be for some other offense related to degradation of resources or public health and safety issues. Law Enforcement Officers in the field have discretion in applying the laws and regulations as necessary and appropriate to protect the natural resources on the ground.
Thank you for your patience, while BLM researched the issue in order to provide accurate answers for your audience,
Carrie Templin
Public Affairs Specialist
Bureau of Land Management
Arizona State Office
(602) 417-9448
The link above to the ADEQ deals mostly with home use of gray water recycling, and offers the following definition: "Gray water is defined as wastewater, collected separately from sewage, that originates from a clothes washer, bathtub, shower or sink, but not from a kitchen sink, dishwasher or toilet. Gray water is distinguished from 'black water,' which is wastewater from toilets, kitchen sinks and dishwashers."
Of particular note is that a citation could occur in a situation that went "beyond simple gray water dumping, and the citation would likely be for some other offense related to degradation of resources or public health and safety issues."
That is about as clear as we're going to get as an interpretation of the rules.
thanks bob for the information
thanks bob for the information
No comments:
Post a Comment